Karla Pomeroy

The Old Cookie Shop DAILY NEWS/Karla Pomeroy Mrs. Rosie O'Grady (Naomi Durrant) reacts to the news that Dr. Gilbert (right, Dan Frederick) gave her that Mortimer Whiplash (Lew Markley) is really her son, with two babies having been switched in the hospital nursery years ago. "The Old Cookie Shop" melodrama was part of the Heroes and Villains" production at the Washakie Museum last Saturday afternoon.